Category Archives: education

Most Experts Agree

From now on, whenever I hear or read “most experts believe” used rhetorically, I am going to ask “how many out of how many?” Here is why:

  • I do not believe the veracity such claims unless I see actual data backing them up.
  • I believe that such a survey of expert opinions is practically impossible due to boundaries of time, location, language, persistence of publishing, and the ephemeral nature of opinions.
  • I do not believe there is an equitable or sensible solution as to which votes to count and which to exclude in a survey of expert opinions.
  • Such statements are an appeal to authority fallacy if used rhetorically.

In other words, I find it unlikely that anyone can actually authoritatively say “most experts believe” anything, and I think the matter of expert opinion is irrelevant in any case. So why are such rhetorical phrases used so frequently?

Note: This article of mine was previously published on another site.

Now an SBL member

Yesterday I noticed a pilots’ organization magazine belonging to my brother-in-law, and it lit a fuse in my brain. I should be a member of a “trade” association for my field.

So I signed up for the Society of Biblical Literature. It is obviously a pertinent choice for my studies of the Bible. The main benefit for me is access to their journal JBL. However, it will also be helpful to be a bit more “plugged-in” to the field than I have been. I signed up for the cheaper associate membership, since I don’t expect to be submitting papers in the next year. Hopefully it is worth the money.

Short Goliath word cloud

My thesis Short Goliath as a word cloud:

Image generated by Wordle.

Expensive scholarly works

Many published works of Christian scholarship are incredibly expensive to purchase. That and being in dead-tree form makes the data less useful to those whom it is intended to benefit. Ulrich Schmid expresses frustration:

Concerning the pricing of scholarly literature in Biblical studies it is time that scholars themselves start to think about their roles as content providers. It’s not just that the books are so expensive, but all the work that goes into publishing such literature is basically done by the scholars as well. Sky-high prizing despite having the manuscripts delivered camera-ready is a situation that I am increasingly fed up with. What do other content providers think about that?

Maurice Robinson seems to have the same sentiment I do:

I seriously wonder what all the publishers of those ridiculously expensive limited-print volumes would do if the various scholarly writers (who often get little or no payment or royalty for such works) would eschew such costly publication formats, and get together to offer at a common website free PDF downloads of their camera-ready scholarly works. That way — bypassing the print media entirely — a wider audience could be had, even offering the material in printed hardback or paperback format through the various low-cost on-demand publishing entities such as Lulu or Lightning Source. Something to think about, certainly.

I would go farther than Robinson. I think the source files of the work should be distributed as well, since this makes the scholarship easier to convert for various uses. Also, I would ensure that the works are libre and not just gratis.

Thesis Success

Today I had my thesis oral exam. It went well and I was awarded a passing grade! This means that I have finished my M.A. (apart from paying any outstanding library fines).

A Free Software Thesis

Last year I set out to produce my master’s thesis using only free software. Having turned in my final copy today, I can report a qualified success.

Despite some early interest in using Lyx (maybe someday in another life), I ended up going with a standard word processor in the form of OpenOffice (and its cousin NeoOffice). The downside in doing so is that I would have to deal directly with formatting issues. Thankfully OpenOffice has some versatile formatting styles which allowed me to satisfy the crazy formatting requirements (seriously – can I have a type-setting degree too?).

As for operating system, I was split between Gentoo Linux (free software) and Mac OS X (decidedly un-free software), where I did the majority of the actual typing. This is where the qualified yes comes in. It has nothing to do with any deficiency of Gentoo or OpenOffice. Rather I only had one machine available, and it had to be running Mac OS X for another reason, so it was just a matter of convenience. As it turned out, some font rendering problems in NeoOffice brought me back to Gentoo, which is the platform upon which I produced the final form of my thesis.

It all worked out in the end. So yes, it is possible to craft a big, important paper using free software tools.

Thesis Done

I have finished revision and formatting and proofreading and polishing, and I am ready to turn my thesis in tomorrow. Finally! It feels good to have that monkey off my back. Will post the final result soon.

In other news, I think we heard an escaped monkey in the wetlands. I am not making this up.

Thesis First Draft Done

I have completed the first draft of my thesis Short Goliath, which is an examination in the textual discrepency between the Hebrew Masoretic Text and the Old Greek (a.k.a. Septuagint) accounts of the story of David and Goliath.  This feels really good, because it has been a long time coming, including a break from working on it for most of last semester.  Now I will start the revision process, which will be fairly involved.  The final draft is due the first week of April.  Once I have the paper in a form I like, I will be posting it here under a Creative Commons license. Here are some gory details:

  • 83 pages
  • 23,656 words
  • File saved: 477 times
  • Total edit time: over 45 hours (just on this one document – doesn’t even come close to total time committed)
  • File created: April 22, 2008